Accomodations you have a reasonable right to ask for, under 504

I was looking around the internet for more information on the lawsuit that happened at Boston College [more appropriately to my knowledge, a college in boston] in 1997-98 when I came across a website with Legal Information and Resources on 504 accomodations in college settings. There was an abstract from a book/paper that was listed among the resources that had a HUGE list of possible suggestions. Some of these suggestions I had been coming toward on my own, but didn't know *could* be included, and others were TOTALLY beyond what I would have expected. Needless to say, they proved my point in my other post, My Views on 504 Accomodations.

The few suggestions that my college DID offer me will be boldfaced, suggestions that I've pursued on my own will be italicized, and other noteworthy ones I've thought about asking for will be marked with an asterisk.

In full, here is the abstract of the book and its info, taken from http://www.classaccommodation.org/legal_information_and_resources.htm, the site I mentioned above:

Author(s): Latham, Patricia H.; Latham, Peter S.
Corporate Author: National Center for Law and Learning Disabilities,
Cabin John, MD. [BBB35202]
Title: Attention Deficit Disorder in College: Faculty and Students.
Partners in Education. Source: 1998. 7p.
Abstract: This publication provides an overview of attention deficit disorders (ADD) and the legal rights of college students with ADD.
Possible accommodations that schools can make for students with ADD
are provided and include: (1) provide structure and reduce
distraction in class; (2) simplify and repeat instructions, as
necessary, both orally and in writing*; (3) give frequent and specific
feedback from faculty and disability services staff*; (4) provide
accommodations such as priority registration, reduced course loads*,
taped textbooks, tape recorders, course modifications*, tailored
assignments, modified text books, priority seating in the front of
the room, study guides, and summaries of important points; (5)
provide test accommodations such as extra time, quiet room,
alternative formats, and opportunities to seek clarification; (6)
allow course substitutions to fulfill certain requirements, e.g., for
foreign language and mathematics; (7) offer as electives alternative
learning style courses; (8) educate the student regarding ADD, coping
strategies, and advocacy techniques; (9) encourage the use of support
groups, counselors and advisors to assist with academic, career and
other issues; and (10) review rules and expectations and use
behavioral management techniques as needed. Possible strategies for
students with ADD are provided and a list of organizational resources
is included. (CR)
Availability: National Center for Law and Learning Disabilities, P.O.
Box 368, Cabin John, MD 20818; telephone: 301-469-8308; fax:
301-469-9466.
Accession Number: ED422699

One thing that wasn't mentioned that my college suggested, that I thought was pretty cool, was that they could get me a note-taker to help me take notes during classes, in addition to me writing my own notes; they could give another student in the class a carbon-copy notebook that they could then give copies to me from, among other things.

To be honest, though, I was pretty ticked off when I looked at this full list. I wound up using a digital recorder of my own (which was AMAZING), but was surprised that it was something that could have been offered by the schools. Adding course modifications, study guides, summaries and tailored assignments to the list pretty much threw me over the edge. Why wasn't I told? Why didn't I find out about this until AFTER I graduated? It was both liberating and infuriating at once - because I knew I was justified in being frustrated at the time, and could let others know what they can reasonably request. The one thing I don't know (and still don't have an answer to), however, is whether the school is obligated to suggest or fund these ideas. The answer to that question could be damning to a lot of districts and colleges.

Course modifications were one thing that I REALLY favored and was never sure were appropriate to ask for. Specifically, I'm talking about grade weighting. There were many times I felt like I was doomed the moment I saw that two or three papers were going to be 30-50% of my grade or more. I failed, barely passed, or dropped most of these classes due to extreme problems getting my ideas to the page on command. If I could shift emphasis to my strong areas (test taking), or if that emphasis was already there, I was virtually always guaranteed a minimum of a low B. I believe difficulty in writing papers (which I often flat out didn't) dropped my final GPA one full point.

Reduced course loads are a...somewhat dubious suggestion. For one, most on 504 are somewhat self-conscious about asking for help. Many times, ADDers get questioned/pressured about the validity of their requests from other students. It's a serious hassle, and often gets in their way of asking for VALID accomodations. It's sad that ADDers need to be encouraged to even ask for things they need to survive the system. To those who wonder: ADDers aren't looking for easy street, and it's difficult to acknowledge there's a problem. It doesn't surprise me that there's a high incidence of depression among students with learning disabilities.

I have also seen "reduced course load" suggested as a reduced credit load per semester. Don't get me wrong - when I've had to drop classes halfway through the semester it felt GREAT to only have three classes! I had more than enough time for everything. However, I feel that this is an incredibly unrealistic suggestion - I don't know of many (any?) standard scholarships OR loans that will last more than 8 semesters. If you don't have your credits/credit hours complete by then, what are you supposed to do? More often than not, lack of finances cause people to drop out. If finances DON'T force these people out of school, the falling grades from trying to do homework while working part-time or full-time to support tuition probably WILL.

More of these suggestions will be covered over time. First to mind are working with professors to structure grading, suggestions on paper-writing, and uses for a tape/digital recorder.

My views on 504 Accomodations

I have been using 504 Accomodations ever since I started taking meds for my ADD; which was in 7th grade. I've been using them long enough to understand what goes on with them, behind them, and how they're typically used - and I have a few things to say about them.

Overview

504 Accomodations, as I mentioned in my post "Why be diagnosed with ADD/HD?" require by law that schools and colleges do everything in their power to assist you to succeed...a lawsuit at Boston College between '97-'98 cemented that into place. This is in place to protect people with mental disabilities, of which ADD is included, from discrimination. It allows affected students to request accomodations with their studies (of which, I intended this blog to guide you) - including, but not limited to, extra time on tests, papers and projects.

The way the school system is set up works ENTIRELY against ADD/HD - such students are constantly tested on their worst weaknesses (assignments demanding hours of focus with little reinforcement or 'checkpoints' to gauge progress from), and it is an incredible nightmare to survive at times. When attempting physics homework, I would get physically tired if I tried to focus on a single problem for more than 15-30 minutes in one sitting (meds lenghtened this limit immensely). Likewise, if I was in a boring lecture, I would get extremely sleepy after 30-40 minutes. Heat or afternoon classes (2:30-4 pm was the worst) intensified this effect.

This is in addition to the assumed problems of scheduling time for writing papers, difficulties in writing papers, procrastinating the writing of said papers...

Purpose/Use of 504

Enter the 504 Accomodations. In my experience, the main use of 504 accomodations is to shield you from the worst consequences of 'screwing up' while in the system. As I said in my post about why you'd want a ADD/HD diagnosis, this alone is worth the price tag of an official diagnosis.

504 Accomodations allow you to ask for extensions on papers, get additional time to take tests, and so forth. This has also included reduced or eliminated penalties for late work, in the past. As I said, 504 is more of a shield than anything else...but a VERY necessary one! I doubt I would have graduated without using 504. Also - there were times when I tried to go without it, feeling like I relied on it too much. Don't make that mistake. Those accomodations are there for a reason - to protect you! I feel like, as a student, you need to do what you can to protect yourself from harm and loss. 504 is a solid way of doing that.

Limitations of the School System

I am grateful to an ex for helping me let go of the bitterness and anger I constantly felt toward the system, and that allowed me to see more of what was really going on. The system wasn't consciously trying to bring me down...what's happening is that - because 504 is still a relatively new thing for them to deal with - they're short on ideas.

One of my biggest frustrations was in going consistently to counseling centers and hearing the exact same limited ideas over and over - of which none changed anything. Extra test time, extensions on paper, seat in the front, ability to leave once during long classes to stretch; year in, and year out.

One of the main problems I have with 504 is that I feel like it's sometimes used as a copout by the system. Instead of truly changing to help the students, the system can offer a few suggestions and simply shrug its shoulders. They're complying with the law, and that's all that matters. They expect you to come up with the majority of solutions. To a point, this is okay - you have a better idea of your strengths and weaknesses than they do - but they are the ones who deal with hundreds of students every year.

It has been almost ten years since the initial lawsuit at Boston College led to revisions of ADA, and I am only now starting to see improvements in attention to students with LDs. My college has just this year added a position in its counseling department to focus on these students...which would have been nice while I was still there. It's a step in the right direction - these students should not be left to fend for themselves.

Parental Abuse of the System

I have started reading many, many reports on how competitive parents are starting to perceive college entrance requirements to be, and how cutthroat these parents are getting. In addition to going to college advisors (more or less performance coaches) as early as these students' freshman years to make them 'Ivy League material' (I believe some of this is documented in the book "Branded," by Alissa Quart), it's getting to the point where some of them are forcing doctors and psychologists to give their kids false diagnoses for LDs (Learning Disabilities)!

I have zero tolerance for this kind of behavior, and giving normal kids advantages they don't need infuriates me. 504 and ADD/HD coping tools can be looked at like a pair of eyeglasses (Drs. Hallowell and Ratey, authors of "Driven to Distraction," use this analogy) - someone who is nearsighted won't be able to see clearly until they have glasses to correct their vision. In this context, giving normal students these accomodations is like giving them a pair of binoculars! I find this kind of action by these parents dishonest, immoral, and inexcusable.

As I was beginning this post, I came across some resources that can help you understand what you can legally ask for/expect from your colleges/schools to help you with; only a tiny fraction of these were offered to me. In another post, I will share these resources along with my own spin.